| Side-by-side comparison |
| |
Hard-shell tents— In general, fiberglass (hard-shell) roof top tents are better if you are going to leave the tent mounted on your vehicle all, or most, of the time. These tents deploy very quickly, provide comfort in any weather, and offer little air resistance when driving. |
 |
 |
 |
| Designed for 4 season use and tested world-wide. |
Lightweight simple, hard-shell tent that's easy to set up. |
The world's most advanced roof top camper. |
| Maggiolina |
Columbus |
Columbus Carbon |
| Design Strengths |
Excellent for cold weather. Deploys quickly Low air resistance while traveling |
Light weight and simplicity of operation. Instant deployment. Low air resistance while traveling |
Super light carbon fiber shell – tough as steel. Instant deployment. Low air resistance while traveling. |
| Weather Protection |
Excellent in cold, wet climates. Good in hot weather |
Excellent in hot, humid climates. Good in cold weather |
Excellent in hot, humid climates. Good in cold weather |
|
Excellent |
Very Good |
Very Good |
| Security when closed |
Excellent—crank handle acts as a ‘key’ |
Locking rear latch to secure contents |
Locking rear latch to secure contents |
| Storage space |
Excellent to good |
Good |
Good |
| Comfort |
Excellent |
Excellent |
Excellent |
| Interior Space |
Good - but Low ceiling f(35” to 38”) or warmth retention |
Good – excellent head room |
Good – excellent head room |
| Ease of Deployment |
Opens quickly – 30 to 45 seconds |
Almost instant – 5 to 10 seconds |
Almost instant – 5 to 10 seconds |
| Ventilation |
Very good—two doors two vent windows breathable fabric |
Excellent —three doors large vent window |
Excellent —three doors large vent window |
| Privacy |
Excellent, especially Grand Tour and Extreme |
Very Good – flexible door options |
Very Good – flexible door options |
| Access |
Two doors – Enter on either side |
Three doors – enter either side or rear |
Three doors – enter either side or rear |
| Insect Protection |
Fully screened openings – zip separately on doors |
Fully screened openings – zip separately on doors |
Fully screened openings – zip separately on doors |
| Fuel economy impact |
Low |
Low |
Very low |
| Wind noise when driving |
Very low – not noticeable |
Very low – not noticeable |
Very low – not noticeable |
| Bedding |
Carried in place |
Carried in place |
Carried in place |
| |
| |
Fabric tents— For maximum interior space in the smallest possible package, choose an all-fabric tent. They are also able to take a lot of abuse. These high quality tents do offer more frontal air resistance than our hard-shell models when driving at highway speeds. |
| |
 |
 |
 |
| |
OverZone |
OverLand |
OverCamp |
| Design Strengths |
Maximum interior space. Rugged & durable. Good interior space |
Maximum interior space. Rugged & durable Good interior space |
Maximum interior space. Rugged & durable Good interior space |
| Weather Protection |
Very good all-around protection integral awning protects entry. |
Very good all-around protection. |
Excellent in warm weather. Good all-season |
| Wind Capability |
Very Good |
Very Good |
Very Good |
| Security when closed |
Good—but not lockable |
Good—but not lockable |
Good—but not lockable |
| Storage space |
None |
None |
None |
| Comfort |
Very Good mattress thickness is limited due to folding design |
Very Good mattress thickness is limited due to folding design |
Very Good mattress thickness is limited due to folding design |
| Interior Space |
Excellent |
Excellent |
Excellent |
| Ease of Deployment |
Good – about 3 minutes |
Good – about 3 minutes |
Good – about 3 minutes |
| Ventilation |
Excellent —two large doors and end vents |
Excellent —two large doors and end vents |
Excellent —two large doors and end vents |
| Privacy |
Excellent – awning aids privacy |
Excellent when doors are closed |
Excellent when doors are closed |
| Access |
Two doors – Enter on one side only |
Two doors – Enter on one side only |
Two doors – Enter on one side only |
| Insect Protection |
Fully screened openings – zip separately on doors |
Fully screened openings – zip separately on doors |
Fully screened openings – zip separately on doors |
| Fuel economy impact |
Higher at highway speeds |
Higher at highway speeds |
Higher at highway speeds |
| Wind noise when driving |
Moderate – depends on mounting |
Moderate – depends on mounting |
Moderate – depends on mounting |
| Bedding |
Most bedding can be carried in place |
Most bedding can be carried in place |
Most bedding can be carried in place |
| |